Top-Rated Pizzeria in Sherrill, NY

Name: Italian Sizzle Shack
Address: Italian Sizzle Shack, 190 E State St, Sherrill, NY 13461
Rating: 4.5

Held by Italian Sizzle Shack · 4.5★ · 68 reviews · 2026

Meritly Verified

Top-Rated Pizzeria

SHERRILL, NY · 2026

This award is held by

Italian Sizzle Shack

4.5★ · 68 verified customer reviews

Determined solely by the holder's public customer review record, measured against the published Meritly standard of 4.5★ across 30 or more reviews.

MTLY-NY-2026-6TDPGW

Verification copy

Put it on the wall — order the plaque Download seal + playbook (PDF) Run a new check

The plaque and the framed certificate above are made to order with this exact award. Free US shipping, about a week to your door.

This page re-checks the holder's live Google record every time it is opened. The seal may be displayed on the holder's website, window and materials for the awarded year. The printed, framed certificate is issued with the plaque + certificate set.

The holder

Italian Sizzle Shack

Italian Sizzle Shack, 190 E State St, Sherrill, NY 13461

Visit website View on the map Suggest an edit

This page links out to toasttab.com as a followed link — part of the award, free, and not conditional on buying anything.

Awarded as Pizzeria in Sherrill, NY. Wrong trade? Use “Suggest an edit”.

More: Pizzerias in Sherrill, NY · every verified business in Sherrill, NY · Pizzerias nationwide