Meritly

Browse › New York, NY › Pizza Restaurants

Top-Rated Pizza Restaurants in New York, NY

45 businesses in New York, NY clear the Meritly standard in this category — a 4.5★ or better rating across 30 or more public Google reviews. Each name links to its verification page, with the rating from Meritly's most recent check.

Top-Rated Pizza Restaurant — New York, NY
Pizzazz
5★ · 1,119 verified reviews
Verify →
Top-Rated Pizza Restaurant — New York, NY
Aria Nova Pizzeria
5★ · 593 verified reviews
Verify →
Top-Rated Pizza Restaurant — New York, NY
Slicehaus Pizzeria
5★ · 564 verified reviews
Verify →
Top-Rated Pizza Restaurant — New York, NY
LaVista Pizza (2nd Ave)
4.9★ · 1,275 verified reviews
Verify →
Top-Rated Pizza Restaurant — New York, NY
Quality Pizza Co. Midtown
4.8★ · 2,020 verified reviews
Verify →
Top-Rated Pizza Restaurant — New York, NY
Nolita Pizza
4.8★ · 1,612 verified reviews
Verify →
Top-Rated Pizza Restaurant — New York, NY
Cello's Pizzeria
4.8★ · 1,053 verified reviews
Verify →
Top-Rated Pizza Restaurant — New York, NY
Abitino’s Pizza Financial District
4.8★ · 691 verified reviews
Verify →
Top-Rated Pizza Restaurant — New York, NY
Previti Pizza 34th
4.8★ · 458 verified reviews
Verify →
Top-Rated Pizza Restaurant — New York, NY
PIZZA DAA ROMA & BAGEL
4.8★ · 339 verified reviews
Verify →
Top-Rated Pizza Restaurant — New York, NY
Madison Pizza NYC
4.8★ · 248 verified reviews
Verify →
Top-Rated Pizza Restaurant — New York, NY
Patsy's Pizzeria Flatiron
4.8★ · 203 verified reviews
Verify →
Top-Rated Pizza Restaurant — New York, NY
Rosetta Pizza & Restaurant
4.8★ · 180 verified reviews
Verify →
Top-Rated Pizza Restaurant — New York, NY
La Pizza Napoli 🇮🇹
4.8★ · 118 verified reviews
Verify →
Top-Rated Pizza Restaurant — New York, NY
L’industrie Pizzeria - West Village
4.7★ · 4,285 verified reviews
Verify →
Top-Rated Pizza Restaurant — New York, NY
Song' E Napule
4.7★ · 2,719 verified reviews
Verify →
Top-Rated Pizza Restaurant — New York, NY
La Pizza Italia
4.7★ · 2,069 verified reviews
Verify →
Top-Rated Pizza Restaurant — New York, NY
My Pie Pizzeria Romana
4.7★ · 1,856 verified reviews
Verify →
Top-Rated Pizza Restaurant — New York, NY
ANDIAMO PIZZA
4.7★ · 1,689 verified reviews
Verify →
Top-Rated Pizza Restaurant — New York, NY
Roma Pizza & restaurant
4.7★ · 1,687 verified reviews
Verify →
Top-Rated Pizza Restaurant — New York, NY
Underground Pizza
4.7★ · 926 verified reviews
Verify →
Top-Rated Pizza Restaurant — New York, NY
Napoli Pizza
4.7★ · 917 verified reviews
Verify →
Top-Rated Pizza Restaurant — New York, NY
La Pizza Italia 🇮🇹
4.7★ · 767 verified reviews
Verify →
Top-Rated Pizza Restaurant — New York, NY
SIMÒ PIZZA - MIDTOWN
4.7★ · 627 verified reviews
Verify →
Top-Rated Pizza Restaurant — New York, NY
L’industrie Pizzeria - Little Italy
4.7★ · 596 verified reviews
Verify →
Top-Rated Pizza Restaurant — New York, NY
LTD Pizza and Bar
4.7★ · 542 verified reviews
Verify →
Top-Rated Pizza Restaurant — New York, NY
Square Pizza NYC: Times Square
4.7★ · 425 verified reviews
Verify →
Top-Rated Pizza Restaurant — New York, NY
ANDIAMO PIZZA
4.7★ · 406 verified reviews
Verify →
Top-Rated Pizza Restaurant — New York, NY
Baggios Pizzeria
4.7★ · 370 verified reviews
Verify →
Top-Rated Pizza Restaurant — New York, NY
Marko's Pizzeria
4.7★ · 159 verified reviews
Verify →
Top-Rated Pizza Restaurant — New York, NY
NY Pizza Suprema
4.6★ · 8,894 verified reviews
Verify →
Top-Rated Pizza Restaurant — New York, NY
Kesté Pizza e Vino
4.6★ · 3,471 verified reviews
Verify →
Top-Rated Pizza Restaurant — New York, NY
Capizzi
4.6★ · 2,485 verified reviews
Verify →
Top-Rated Pizza Restaurant — New York, NY
Carnegie Pizza
4.6★ · 2,058 verified reviews
Verify →
Top-Rated Pizza Restaurant — New York, NY
ANDIAMO PIZZA
4.6★ · 967 verified reviews
Verify →
Top-Rated Pizza Restaurant — New York, NY
Roma Pizza
4.6★ · 665 verified reviews
Verify →
Top-Rated Pizza Restaurant — New York, NY
Previti Pasta & Pizza
4.6★ · 529 verified reviews
Verify →
Top-Rated Pizza Restaurant — New York, NY
Romano Pizza Restaurant
4.6★ · 494 verified reviews
Verify →
Top-Rated Pizza Restaurant — New York, NY
See No Evil Pizza
4.6★ · 450 verified reviews
Verify →
Top-Rated Pizza Restaurant — New York, NY
La Citta Pizzeria
4.6★ · 216 verified reviews
Verify →
Top-Rated Pizza Restaurant — New York, NY
Joe’s Pizza
4.5★ · 7,361 verified reviews
Verify →
Top-Rated Pizza Restaurant — New York, NY
Crazy Pizza
4.5★ · 1,050 verified reviews
Verify →
Top-Rated Pizza Restaurant — New York, NY
ANDIAMO PIZZA
4.5★ · 868 verified reviews
Verify →
Top-Rated Pizza Restaurant — New York, NY
Roma Pizza
4.5★ · 394 verified reviews
Verify →
Top-Rated Pizza Restaurant — New York, NY
Broni & Belle's Pizzeria
4.5★ · 91 verified reviews
Verify →

Also in New York, NY

Every verified business in New York, NY Pizza Restaurants nationwide
Every business on this page cleared one published standard — 4.5★ across 30 or more public Google reviews — read from the public record. No business can pay to appear here.

Check your own business free →